Project Managing AI: Why Traditional Methods Fall Short and How to Adapt

Project management has long relied on established methodologies, honed through years of experience in software development, infrastructure deployments, and business process re-engineering. Waterfall, Agile, and Scrum have become familiar frameworks, offering structured approaches to planning, execution, and delivery. However, as Artificial Intelligence (AI) moves from research labs to practical applications, project managers are discovering that these traditional methods, while valuable, often fall short in the face of AI’s unique challenges. The key is understanding why these shortcomings exist and learning how to adapt.

Traditional IT projects typically involve well-defined requirements, predictable timelines, and readily available data. Consider a project to develop a new customer relationship management (CRM) system. The desired functionalities are outlined, the database structure is meticulously planned, and user interfaces are designed based on established principles. Testing focuses on ensuring the system performs as expected, handles data accurately, and integrates seamlessly with existing infrastructure. Success is measured by metrics like on-time delivery, budget adherence, and user satisfaction.

AI projects, on the other hand, are inherently experimental. The goal is often to build a system that learns from data and makes predictions or decisions. This process is less about building a predefined system and more about training a model. You might start with a clear objective – say, predicting customer churn – but the path to achieving that objective is rarely straightforward.

Here’s where traditional methods stumble:

1. Requirement Definition is Fluid, Not Fixed: In AI, requirements are not always known upfront. You might hypothesize that certain data features will be predictive of customer churn, but you won’t know for sure until you experiment. This necessitates a flexible approach where requirements evolve based on insights gained during model development. Rigidly adhering to pre-defined requirements can lead to wasted effort and a system that fails to deliver the desired outcome. Agile methodologies offer some flexibility, but even they can struggle with the iterative nature of AI model building, which often involves significant pivoting and re-evaluation.

2. Data Quality and Availability are Critical Bottlenecks: AI models are only as good as the data they are trained on. Data quality issues, such as missing values, inaccuracies, and biases, can severely impact model performance. Similarly, limited data availability can hinder the model’s ability to learn complex patterns. Traditional project management often underestimates the effort required for data collection, cleaning, and preparation. This can lead to significant delays and budget overruns. Furthermore, traditional methods often lack specific processes for evaluating and mitigating bias within the data, a critical concern for ethical and responsible AI development.

3. Success is Measured by Model Performance, Not Just Delivery: In traditional IT projects, success is often measured by metrics like on-time delivery, budget adherence, and user satisfaction. While these metrics are still important in AI projects, the ultimate measure of success is the performance of the AI model. This means focusing on metrics like accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score. Achieving acceptable model performance often requires iterative experimentation and fine-tuning, which can be time-consuming and unpredictable. Traditional methods that prioritize deadlines over performance can result in a poorly performing AI system that fails to deliver business value.

4. Experimentation and Failure are Inherent: AI model development is inherently an iterative process of experimentation and failure. Different algorithms, hyperparameter settings, and data preprocessing techniques must be tested to determine the optimal configuration. Many of these experiments will inevitably fail. Traditional project management often views failure as a negative outcome to be avoided at all costs. In AI, however, failure is an opportunity to learn and improve. A culture that embraces experimentation and learns from failures is crucial for successful AI project delivery.

5. Skillsets are Different and Often Scarce: AI projects require a diverse team with specialized skills in areas like data science, machine learning, statistics, and software engineering. Finding and retaining individuals with these skillsets can be a challenge. Traditional IT teams may lack the necessary expertise to effectively develop and deploy AI systems. This can lead to delays, quality issues, and a lack of innovation. Project managers need to understand these skillsets and actively cultivate a collaborative environment where different expertise can be effectively leveraged.

Adapting for Agile, Adaptive AI Delivery:

So, how can project managers adapt their approach to effectively manage AI projects? The answer lies in embracing agile principles while also incorporating specific best practices tailored for the unique challenges of AI.

• Embrace an Experiment-Driven Approach: Frame the project as a series of experiments, each designed to test a specific hypothesis about the data, algorithms, or model architecture. Define clear success criteria for each experiment and allocate sufficient time and resources for experimentation.
• Prioritize Data Quality and Governance: Invest time and resources in data quality assessment, cleaning, and preparation. Implement data governance policies to ensure data accuracy, consistency, and security. Consider using automated data quality tools to streamline the process.
• Define Clear Model Evaluation Metrics: Establish clear and measurable metrics for evaluating model performance. These metrics should be aligned with the business objectives of the project. Use these metrics to track progress and identify areas for improvement.
• Foster a Culture of Learning and Innovation: Encourage experimentation and learning from failures. Provide the team with opportunities to develop their skills in AI and machine learning. Create a collaborative environment where team members can share knowledge and ideas.
• Implement Continuous Integration and Continuous Deployment (CI/CD) for AI: Automate the process of building, testing, and deploying AI models. This allows for rapid iteration and continuous improvement. Use CI/CD tools specifically designed for AI model development.
• Focus on Explainability and Interpretability: Ensure that the AI models are explainable and interpretable. This is crucial for building trust and ensuring that the models are used responsibly. Use techniques like feature importance analysis and model visualization to understand how the models are making predictions.
• Adopt a “Fail Fast, Learn Faster” Mentality: Encourage rapid prototyping and experimentation. Quickly identify what works and what doesn’t, and adjust the project plan accordingly. This requires a flexible and adaptable approach to project management.
• Leverage Specialized Tools and Platforms: Utilize specialized tools and platforms for AI model development, deployment, and monitoring. These tools can streamline the process and improve efficiency. Examples include cloud-based machine learning platforms and automated machine learning (AutoML) tools.

Successfully managing AI projects requires a shift in mindset. Project managers need to be comfortable with ambiguity, embrace experimentation, and prioritize model performance over strict adherence to deadlines. By adapting traditional methodologies and incorporating AI-specific best practices, project managers can unlock the transformative potential of AI and drive significant business value.

Are you ready to lead your organization through the complexities of AI implementation? Understand the crucial role of leadership, often unseen but vital for success. Learn how to navigate the challenges of AI adoption and ensure your organization thrives in the age of intelligent automation. Purchase the eBook, The Invisible Chief AI Officer: Why Many Businesses Need a Leader They May Not See, at https://shop.mymobilelyfe.com/product/the-invisible-chief-ai-officer-why-many-businesses-need-a-leader-they-may-not-see/ and gain the insights you need to become an effective AI leader.